[1:20 PM] Roneisha Smith
top of page

From Centralized to Decentralized Decisions: Agile vs. Predictive Integration Management

Project Integration Management includes the processes and activities to identify, define, combine, unify, and coordinate the various processes and project management activities within the Project Management Process Groups." In this article, we would analyze the various processes and activities involved in an agile and also traditional project setting. Traditional project management integration involves the development of the entire project management plan, directing and managing project work, knowledge, monitoring, and control as well as closing or phase transition.

In Agile project management, integration is more collaborative, with team members empowered as domain experts. It shifts responsibility from the project manager to the team, promoting greater ownership and optimizing outcomes.

In the following sections, we will delve into the specific activities and processes involved in integration management in traditional project management and compare them to how they are handled in Agile approaches. Deliverable due dates, project life cycle, and project objectives: Traditional project management typically sets fixed deliverable due dates, following a linear project life cycle. Deliverables are planned and scheduled upfront, with a focus on meeting predefined deadlines. Project objectives are established early on and remain relatively static throughout the project duration.

Agile methodologies, such as Scrum, have due dates for deliverables that are more flexible. Agile projects adopt an iterative and incremental approach, with shorter time frames called sprints or iterations. Project life cycles are adaptive, allowing for changes in requirements and scope. Objectives evolve with each iteration as the team continuously learns and adapts based on customer feedback and changing priorities.

Creation and use of appropriate knowledge, performance, and changes:

Traditional project management places significant emphasis on extensive upfront planning, documentation, and knowledge transfer. Detailed project plans, requirements documents, and standard operating procedures are created to guide project execution. Knowledge is captured and shared through formal channels, such as documentation and training. Changes are managed through change control processes, requiring formal approval and documentation.

Agile methodologies promote knowledge sharing through collaboration, self-organizing teams, and adaptive planning. Rather than extensive upfront planning, Agile teams prioritize collaboration and communication. Knowledge is shared informally through face-to-face interactions, daily stand-ups, and continuous feedback loops. Agile embraces change, with a focus on responding to customer needs and adapting plans as necessary in an iterative manner.

Integrated decisions, measuring and monitoring progress, and data analysis:

In traditional project management, decisions are often centralized, with key decisions made by project managers or stakeholders. Hierarchical structures and formal reporting mechanisms are in place. Progress is measured periodically, and milestone-based reports are generated. Data analysis is typically performed at predefined intervals to assess project performance and identify areas for improvement.

Agile methodologies promote decentralized decision-making, empowering self-organizing teams to make decisions collaboratively. Progress is measured continuously and transparently. Agile teams use visual management tools, such as information radiators and task boards, to monitor progress and communicate status in real time. Data analysis is performed on an ongoing basis to obtain immediate insights for adaptive decision-making.

Communication and project closure:

Traditional project management relies on formal communication channels, such as status reports, progress meetings, and formal project closure processes. Communication tends to follow predefined reporting structures and is often documented for future reference. Project closure involves formal sign-off, handover processes, and documentation of lessons learned. Agile methodologies foster frequent and transparent communication. Daily stand-up meetings enable team members to share progress, discuss challenges, and coordinate efforts. Information radiators, such as visible task boards, display real-time project status. Agile projects have continuous closure with each iteration, allowing for ongoing feedback, retrospectives, and adaptations based on customer and stakeholder input.

Phase transitions:

Traditional project management approaches involve distinct phase transitions with predefined gates and sign-offs. Projects move through sequential phases, such as initiation, planning, execution, monitoring and control, and closure. Each phase has specific deliverables, entry and exit criteria, and formal approvals.

Agile methodologies, like Scrum, emphasize continuous integration and delivery. Rather than distinct phase transitions, Agile projects have iterative and incremental development cycles. Integration occurs continuously as features and functionalities are developed and tested incrementally. This approach reduces the risk of integration challenges at the end of the project, enabling faster feedback and value delivery.

Comparing traditional and Agile project management reveals contrasting approaches. Each Agile framework (SAFe, SoS, DAD, LeSS) offers unique integration solutions. All emphasize collaboration, communication, and adaptability. Transitioning requires a mindset shift, choosing the right framework, and fostering effective communication and teamwork. Are you seeking to implement Scrum in your organization? We're here to assist you. Get in touch with us now at https://mutreesolutions.com/contact


bottom of page